You Got Denied a Job You Were Qualified For. Here's Why Your Background Check Might Be to Blame.

You applied for a job. You nailed the interview. They liked you. Then, a few days later, you get a call: the offer is being rescinded. No real explanation. Just that something came up in your background check.

You've never been arrested. You've never had a serious legal issue. But somehow, a background screening report — a document you've never even seen — just cost you a job you worked hard to get.

This is not a rare scenario. According to the National Consumer Law Center, tens of millions of background check reports are run every year in the United States, and errors appear far more often than the companies running them would like to admit. Criminal records get misattributed to the wrong person. Old cases that were dismissed or expunged show up anyway. Names, dates of birth, and Social Security numbers get mixed up between people. And the person who suffers the consequences is always the job applicant — not the company that got it wrong.

What Background Check Companies Are Required to Do Under the Law

Background screening companies — companies like Checkr, HireRight, Sterling, First Advantage, and hundreds of others — are considered consumer reporting agencies under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, or FCRA. That means they have legal obligations. They cannot just throw data onto a report and call it a day.

Under the FCRA, these companies must:

▸  Use reasonable procedures to make sure the information they report is accurate

▸  Match criminal records or other sensitive information to the correct person before including it on a report

▸  Give you a copy of your report and a notice of your rights before an employer takes adverse action against you based on it

▸  Give you a reasonable amount of time to dispute any information you believe is wrong before the employer's decision becomes final

▸  Investigate your dispute and correct or delete inaccurate information after you challenge it

Employers also have obligations. Before they reject you based on a background report, they must send you a pre-adverse action notice — meaning they have to tell you what they found and give you a chance to respond before the decision is final. Many employers skip this step entirely. When they do, that is its own separate violation of federal law.

What Kind of Errors Show Up on Background Reports?

The most common and damaging background check errors include:

▸  Misattributed criminal records — someone else's arrest or conviction appearing on your report because you share a similar name or date of birth

▸  Expunged or sealed records that should have been cleared from your history but continue appearing

▸  Dismissed charges reported as convictions

▸  Incorrect identity information — wrong Social Security numbers, wrong addresses, or wrong dates of birth that cause your report to pull up someone else's data

▸  Records from states where reporting restrictions apply that get included anyway

▸  Old cases that are past the legally reportable time period still showing up

"A background check error is not just an inconvenience. It can cost you a job, an apartment, a promotion — and it can follow you for months or years if no one holds the company accountable."

What You Can Do About It

If you have been denied a job or housing because of a background check, here is what to do:

▸  Request a copy of the report that was used against you — the employer is required by law to provide one

▸  Review it carefully and identify every inaccuracy, whether it is a record that doesn't belong to you or information that is outdated

▸  Submit a formal written dispute to the screening company

▸  Contact an attorney before the dispute period expires — time matters in these cases

Under the FCRA, if a background check company violated your rights, you may be entitled to recover actual damages (including lost wages from the job you didn't get), statutory damages of up to $1,000 per violation, and attorney's fees. That last part is important — it means the company that wronged you often ends up paying for your legal representation.

‍

If you think you may have a case, Consumer Rights Law, PLLC offers free consultations and works on contingency — you pay nothing unless we win. Call (786) 360-7697 or visit consumerrights.law.

Consumer Rights Law, PLLC — Prior results do not guarantee similar outcomes. This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or create an attorney-client relationship.