A Florida Jury Awarded $7.5 Million to a Man Who Slipped in a Burger King Restroom. Then the Case Got Even More Complicated.

A patron walked into a Burger King restaurant in Broward County, Florida. He went to use the restroom. The floor was slippery. He fell and sustained serious spinal injuries — injuries that ultimately required disc replacement surgery.

When the case went before a jury, the result was one of the largest slip and fall verdicts in Florida history: $7.5 million. The jury found that the restaurant's failure to maintain safe restroom conditions had caused injuries significant enough to warrant that award.

What happened next illustrates something important about high-stakes Florida premises liability cases: a large verdict is not always the end of the story.

The case — Seven Restaurants, LLC v. Tulecki, decided by Florida's Fourth District Court of Appeal in 2024 — was reversed and sent back for a new trial. The reason was not that the jury was wrong about the defendant's negligence or about the severity of the plaintiff's injuries. The reversal was granted because of a procedural issue: the late disclosure of changed expert testimony. The court found that the defense had not been given adequate notice that the plaintiff's expert would significantly change his opinions close to trial.

This is not a story about a plaintiff who lost. It is a story about how complex these cases can become — and why the quality of legal representation matters every step of the way.

Why Restaurant Restroom Slip and Falls Are Especially Dangerous Cases

Restroom floors are high-risk environments. They are subject to constant moisture from sinks, toilets, and tracked-in water. They receive heavy foot traffic throughout the day. And they are areas where businesses routinely understaff and under-inspect — relying on shift-end cleaning routines rather than regular checks throughout service hours.

Under Florida law, a business must have actual or constructive knowledge of a dangerous condition before liability attaches. But constructive knowledge — what the business should have known — can be established through evidence that the condition existed long enough that a reasonable inspection schedule would have caught it, or that the type of hazard was so routine and foreseeable in that area that the business should have anticipated it.

A restaurant bathroom that is regularly subject to wet floors, and that is inspected infrequently, presents exactly this kind of foreseeable hazard. When a customer is seriously injured as a result, the business cannot escape liability simply by claiming it did not know about the specific puddle on the specific day.

What the Tulecki Case Teaches About Florida Slip and Fall Litigation

The $7.5 million verdict — and the appellate reversal — illustrate several things that are critical for anyone injured in a Florida premises liability case:

• Large verdicts are achievable when the injuries are serious and the evidence of negligence is strong
• The procedural management of a case — including expert witness disclosures — can determine whether a favorable verdict survives appeal
• Fast food restaurant chains and their parent franchisors have experienced litigation teams whose job is to reduce or eliminate verdicts
• A new trial ordered on procedural grounds does not mean the underlying case is lost — it means the fight continues

For an injured plaintiff, what this means is simple: if you slip and fall at a fast food restaurant in Florida, the company's insurer will not offer you a fair settlement without understanding that you have capable legal representation prepared to take the case through trial and, if necessary, through appeal.

Your Rights If You Slip and Fall at a Fast Food Restaurant in Florida

Fast food restaurants — McDonald's, Burger King, Wendy's, Taco Bell, Chick-fil-A, and others — are among the most frequently sued defendants in Florida slip and fall litigation. These businesses know that restroom accidents happen. They carry significant liability insurance. And they have legal teams prepared to minimize their exposure.

If you have been injured in a fall at a fast food restaurant, the most important steps are:

• Seek medical attention immediately, even if you feel the injury may be minor
• Report the incident to the restaurant manager and ensure an accident report is completed
• Photograph the area where you fell, including any visible moisture, absence of warning signs, and the condition of the floor
• Obtain the names of any witnesses
• Do not give a recorded statement to the restaurant's insurance adjuster before speaking with an attorney

Florida's two-year statute of limitations for personal injury claims applies to fast food restaurant slip and falls. From the date of your accident, that clock is running.

‍

If you think you may have a case, Consumer Rights Law, PLLC offers free consultations and works on contingency — you pay nothing unless we win. Call (786) 360-7697 or visit consumerrights.law.

Consumer Rights Law, PLLC — Prior results do not guarantee similar outcomes. This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or create an attorney-client relationship.