A Florida Mother Ordered a Dairy-Free Pizza From Whole Foods for Her Severely Allergic Son. The Store Made It Half Dairy.

Lucy Lopes did everything right.

In May 2022, she went to the Whole Foods Market in Clearwater, Florida to order a pizza for her son, Darius Zahrai. Darius has a severe allergy to dairy products — the kind that can trigger anaphylactic shock. Before placing the order, Lopes made the allergy explicitly clear to the store's prepared foods staff. She told them the pizza needed to be made entirely without dairy ingredients, and that no dairy products could come into contact with the pizza, the preparation surfaces, or the packaging during preparation. A Whole Foods staff member confirmed that the pizza would be safe for Darius to eat.

She brought the pizza home. Darius took three bites.

Almost immediately, he suffered a severe allergic reaction. His mother administered his epinephrine auto-injector and called emergency services. He was taken by ambulance to Mease Countryside Hospital, where he was treated for life-threatening symptoms and admitted overnight.

While her son was in the ambulance, Lopes called the Whole Foods employee who had promised her the pizza was safe. What she was told, according to the lawsuit her family later filed, was startling: the pizza had been prepared 'half dairy-free' and 'half dairy' — with nothing separating the two halves.

The Lawsuit Filed in Pinellas County

Darius's parents — Lucy Lopes and Ali Zahrai — filed a negligence lawsuit against Whole Foods Market Group, Inc. in Pinellas County Circuit Court on November 22, 2024. The complaint alleged that Whole Foods failed in its duty to safely prepare food for a customer with a known, disclosed food allergy, and that the store's negligence caused Darius to suffer a severe anaphylactic reaction.

The family is seeking more than $50,000 in damages, including medical expenses, and has demanded a jury trial.

Beyond the immediate medical consequences, the lawsuit describes lasting harm: Darius has grown fearful of eating, particularly at restaurants, and distrusts assurances from food service staff that prepared food is safe for his consumption. The complaint describes this as psychological harm resulting directly from the incident — a consequence courts and juries in food allergy cases have recognized as a legitimate element of damages.

This Is Not an Isolated Pattern — Whole Foods Has a Record of Allergen Failures

The Clearwater lawsuit did not occur in a vacuum. Between February 2022 and February 2024, Whole Foods Market recalled more than 30 food items due to undeclared allergens — a pattern significant enough that the U.S. Food and Drug Administration issued a formal warning to the company about misbranded products lacking proper allergen labeling. The FDA's concerns focused particularly on items sold in deli and bakery sections under the Whole Foods brand — precisely the type of prepared, custom-order food at the center of the Zahrai family's case.

When a grocery store with a documented history of allergen mislabeling fails to properly prepare a custom order for a customer who has explicitly disclosed a life-threatening allergy, the gap between what was promised and what was delivered is significant — and so is the legal responsibility that follows.

What Grocery Store Food Allergy Liability Means in Florida

The common understanding is that food allergy liability applies to restaurants. But grocery stores and their prepared food counters — deli sections, bakeries, custom-order stations, and hot food bars — owe exactly the same duty of care to customers who disclose food allergies.

Under Florida negligence law, a food service provider — including a grocery store preparing custom orders — that:

• Receives an explicit allergy disclosure from a customer before preparing food
• Provides assurance to that customer that the food will be safe
• Then prepares the food in a manner that introduces the disclosed allergen

...has breached its duty of care and is liable for the resulting harm. The existence of a special order or a verbal promise to accommodate an allergy does not reduce liability — it heightens it, because the customer's reliance on that promise is documented and direct.

If Your Child Has a Food Allergy, Read This Before Your Next Grocery Store Run

Custom-prepared food from grocery store counters is not subject to the same labeling requirements as packaged, shelf-stable products. That means allergen information depends entirely on the knowledge and attentiveness of the staff member preparing your order.

• Never assume a verbal assurance is sufficient — ask staff to check with the kitchen or preparation area directly
• When ordering custom items, write down your allergy request and ask staff to confirm in writing if possible
• When you pick up an order, ask again before leaving the store — before your child is at home and the store is no longer reachable
• If you or your child experiences any symptoms after eating a store-prepared item, use the epinephrine auto-injector first — do not wait to see if symptoms resolve on their own
• Preserve any remaining food, receipts, and packaging as potential evidence before seeking medical care if possible

If your child has suffered an allergic reaction to grocery store food that was supposed to be allergen-safe, you may have a legal claim. Consumer Rights Law, PLLC represents food allergy injury victims throughout Florida.

‍

If you think you may have a case, Consumer Rights Law, PLLC offers free consultations and works on contingency — you pay nothing unless we win. Call (786) 360-7697 or visit consumerrights.law.

Consumer Rights Law, PLLC — Prior results do not guarantee similar outcomes. This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or create an attorney-client relationship.